i wish gold is only 1000 per gram but it is not and wife still buying
44.2. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:11:06 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Septa Ppl like harendra don''t buy even @1000 wishing it will do down furthur :)
43. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 8:48:46 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Experts giving it valuation n comparing with FMCG companies .....but they forget to mention that there is no brand here with the company Very capital intensive manufacturing In FMCG brands have pricing power so they have 2 levers on margin price n volume but here in this company only lever is volume .....price will also be in pressure as Pepsi will focus on cost cuttings. Just one rumour or news of Pepsi aligning towards another company can make this company share price to tank so its not a defensive play May be its good for the flipper @525 but its surely not gonna outperform the MKT in medium term if it lists at premium
wrong again twice pepsi has brought it bottlers and very high valuation
43.2. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:16:48 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Point is u as a company coming out with IPO can''t squeeze so much that retail investors keep holding just hope. U must leave at least 20% under the table for larger interest of company , investors n economy. If Fair price of the company is around 500 then u must price it at least 20% below but here company spreading rumour of 600 n then pricing it around fair value to trap small investors.
I AGREE 100% WITH THIS COMMENT 20% I WOULD SAY 25% THUMBS UP
43.4. NeoTrade| Link| Bookmark|
October 10, 2016 4:23:12 AM
IPO Mentor (800+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
This Company is a price taker at both ends...from vendors and customers...very difficult business! Pricing needs to be seen...
42. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 7:58:06 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
As per my calculation profit of not more than 300 cr this year ( septa calculation 325 cr now) coupled with no track record of past profitable performance .....that''s why retail potion is just 10% of issue size.....enterprise value of around 12000 cr ....financially does it make sense to invest?....I leave this to ur wiadom
40.1. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 7:24:40 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
As first half profit is 209 cr and first half is more than 2/3 rd of yearly sales so profit can''t be more than 300 expected for the full year. Even 300 cr is on higher side and so full year diluted eps around 15-16 max.
JUST A CAUTION I WILL WAIT FOR RHP TO BEFORE MAKING THE FINAL DECISION EPS 11 is working fro 209 Crs so another 5.5 for second half and at least 2.5 for interest cost saving works to 11+5.5+2.5 = 18.5 EPS at least at 525 Imo price PE works to 27.63 giving a good 10 PE discount GIVEN FMCG PE IS AROUND 35 TO 45 PE IMO so fair value is (525+190) with 25% MIS gives me Fair value of approx 540
given market leader in its product we could see MIS reduce to 15% to 20% SO FAIR VAULE WOULD BE 600 SO IF IT COMES WITH 525 IPO PRICE MAY LIST AT 600 IMO
I have still not got hold of RHP BTW all do window dressing. Also in my calculation i have taken 85 crs of reduction in financial cost with close to 800 Crs coming to the company this will have good 5 to 6 rupee EPS impact. let wait for the final price band
36. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 3:37:00 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Septa 2 nd quarter sales is 47% of total sales last year so it assumption of 400 core annualizing half year profit of 209cr seems wrong. Sales n profit r way higher in first half than second half....cold drink mkt is very cyclical n skewed towards first half in india
NidHike i have only consider 50% profit this is how i worked out 209cr + 105 Cr ( SECOND HALF) and 50% saving in financial cost ( which is around 190 Cr IN FY 2015 ) so that is another 85cr Comes 400 Cr. I know it skewed towards first half that is reason they are OPENING BOTTLING PLANT IN SOUTHERN HEMISPHERE BY VARUN BEVERAGES TO COUNTER THIS DRAWBACK HITTING THIS SECTOR
AS I HAVE MENTION EARLIER IN THIS FORUM I WAS INVOLVED WITH COCA AMATIL DEMERGE IN LATE 90 SO I KNOW HOW THIS BUSINESS MODEL WORKS .
BTW before Gupa and anyone else ask me what is advantages of opening a unit in south hemisphere the answer is when northern hemisphere have winters they have summers and when they have summers northern hemisphere have winter.....
BTW financial cost saving will real come to effect in 2017 FY so i happy to take only 25% saving of the 85 Cr so ball park of 325 Cr for 2016 is possible with FY 2018 400 cr plus
36.4. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 7:41:09 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Septa Ur assumption is faulty on 2 grounds: 1. When sales in low just 1/3 of yearly sales ..u can''t assume the margin to be inline with 1st half.thus profit will far lower than 105 in second half. ( ur all fixed cost n wages n salaries r paid equally ) 2. U r assuming 50% savings in interest ....when business is in investment mode how u r assuming this . again company is raising just 800 crores through IPO so benefit of this money will be accrued for less than half year in this fy
JUST FOR UR INFO NIDHIKE 90% OF WORKS IN BOTTLING PLANT R CONTRACT WORKERS ALL WITH ROBOTIC TECHNOLOGY USED MANUAL LABOUR IS MINIMUM.... NIDHIKE U HAVE CONSIDER SECOND half DHRP 3,438.38 million litres is produce in india and 991.57 million litres southern hemisphere with company planning more bottling plants.
long run these company will have 50% 50% production in two different hemisphere to counter seasonal nature of this industry .
36.7. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 8:04:58 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
It''s not about being happy or making it wrong. I m just putting my pov n u can always disagree .....be logical
ur r just talking non sense in ur last post u have given of 12000 Cr when at 525@ 19011525 works to less then 10000 crs with debt at 1000 cr give it a EV of 11000 cr so still 10% upside from ur own calculation
i agree second half is always less for this sector that is reason bottling company have combination of south and north Hemp markets. varun have started this exercise soon the product mix will be 50:50
i also told u how have worked my figures anyway i am still not sure if i am going apply at least u r sure u r not applying on this valuation
36.10. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 8:28:32 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
It maybe sound nonsense to u but talking of sense u just forget to mention 650 cr of deferred payment liability towards pepsi and the entire 800 cr money raised not gonna paid towards debt ...money is also used for general purpose which I think will be used for working capital requirements n newer investments Now u at least agreed that 560-600 doesn''t make sense .....525 may be
nidhike i did mention 650 cr deferred payment and also i have not taken 800 crs as full payment present financial cost is 160 crs not sure what is coupon rate should be 15-18% so i am only consider half 85 cr for year 2017 FY. U first get the fact right i really do not know why u only picking half facts to prove ur point. BTW i am actual like people like who question the financial position then those who blessedly praise the company with no financial backing thumbs up for that.
hear again u getting it wrong pepsi and coke business model is same thought the world they grow via franchise model The bottling side of the systems is very much steeped in a history of family-owned, entrepreneurial, community-oriented cultures. In 2009 PepsiCo set a $6 billion bid for its two largest independent bottlers. Tingyi biggest bottler outside USA has a PE of 56. IMO FIIs will participate in this FMCG brand
BTW i never agree even at 560 to 525 price band that i will apply i will only make once the correct price band is out NIDHIKE i sincerely welcome ur comments all the negative comments however not wrong assumptions
36.13. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:01:14 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
wrong again 11.5%is correct that is flat rate effective rate which is real rate which effects the balance sheet is not 11.5% but 19.56% on five year tenure on seven year tenure it more like 18.80%. just look at the numbers in balance sheet interest cost is 160 Cr on a loan of 800 Cr so effective rate is more like 20%.
So pre payment of loan will have good effect on bottom line
that is reason i said coupon rate not interest rate
36.16. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:19:58 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
For ur information see the article - "The company has bank debt amounting to Rs1,450 crore and Rs623 crore of deferred payment obligation towards PepsiCo Inc. for territory acquisition in north India in 2015. For the six months to June, Varun Beverages noted a profit of Rs. 209 crore on revenue of Rs. 2,530 crore. The first half of the year is generally better than the second half on the back of higher consumption of cold drinks during the summer."
i thought u had some basis knowledge now u r just net picking to prove or point so argument stop. Never argue with an idiot. They will only bring you down to their level and beat you with experience
36.18. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:27:00 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
BTW u posting 209 cr profit from heaven???? Rhp still not out as u urself mentioned When I m presenting facts then u deny it. Hope better sense prevail....BTW there r far too many ppl in our world who hit n run
i just said and u r idiot and u proved it that is financial year 2016 which even i know and have already mention i however do not know the interest cost for 2016 if u look at the 2015 outstanding loan is way below
Nidhike hit and run :) u r joking i have been in this forum for long in fact people like u come with hidden agenda and then disappear. At least we r on the same side u are not apply i am saying i will wait for RHP before making my decision. HOW CAN SOMEONE REJECT SOMETHING WHEN HE DOES NOT KNOW THE PRICE SOUNDS FISHY
36.22. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:36:09 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Prominent politician called our PM coward n psychopath n Pakistan relied upon his statement.....n see what happened with pak Now u calling me nonsense n idiot ...hope ppl take informed decision could plz explain where did u pick the figure of 209 cr from??? My pick from net is idiotism n ur pick is heroism???.... It''s called doglapan
AGAIN U RUNNING THE SAME RECORDS I WILL ANSWER IF U ANSWER WHICH EFFECT BALANCE SHEET THE FLAT RATE OR REAL RATE CANNOT ARGUE WITH IDIOTS. BTW I NEVER SAID 209 CR IS WRONG SEE U R PROVING U HAVE A HIDDEN AGENDA
36.24. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:43:11 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Exactly if someone questioning price of 525 look s fishy to u ....but ppl advocating price of even 560-600 doesn''t look fishy to u. Come on I m not rejecting rather I m saying u have to leave for small investors n not loot like our old n reputed group mangers have done in issues like lti icicipru . l&t tech etc.
I ALSO WHAT PEOPLE TO BENEFIT AND THIS FORUM WILL VOUCH THIS FOR U
36.26. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:53:51 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
As per DRHP page no 98.....company intends to utilise 540 cr towards debt repayment and debts r having interest rate of around 11% ....how u r imagining interest saving of 85 cr is beyond logic. Financial prudence teach us to be conservative in our estimate n projections ....I hope u follow this for the benefit of members of the site. I thought of joining n participating the site just to inform members n not to get trapped in this IPO bull mkt
that is magic of numbers u r looking just at interest cost i am looking at real cost. interest cost will be around 60 Crs plus and thumb rule this extra payment will save company at least another 33.33% of interest cost on bottom line that is magic of numbers so i still hold to my point company will benefit more then 85 Crs in 2017 because of the pre payment is money saved is invested they r planing to downward integration will manufacture it own plastic wraps cardboards invest in supply chain etc FY however in 2016 it would be 25% as i mention earlier however log run 2017 onwards will have good effect.
Once goldman sachs VP (who is also my co brother) asked him how did u pick eicher motors when no one notice this big move his words " we start r analysis were u stop ur analysis" those golden words have benefit me a lot in stock picking to look at the real picture and effects then just numbers.
36.29. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 11:28:25 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
If u r saving 60cr on interest then ur PBT goes up by 60Cr n then u have to pay income tax @33.33% of that extra income which means ur net saving is 40 cr only .....again correct ur maths on excelsheet....u r way too aggressive in ur projection n estimations.... My pov
36.30. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 11:35:42 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Septa that''s my whole point....u r not already listed ...eivher was @17.5 in 2001.....when u r coming with IPO u can''t just sell hope u have to sell ur track record also
36.31. Nidhike| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 11:39:59 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
When u talk of Goldman Sachs then u must also tell the story of Lehman.....u can''t alws think of giving ur hat to another persons hoping to get better price .....IPO flipper beware!!!!
34. Septa| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 10:40:46 AM
(4000+ Posts, 4600+ Likes)
Varun beverage for FY 2016 For the first six months to June, Varun Beverages reported a profit of Rs209 crore on a revenue of Rs2,530 crore. If you amplify this for the full year with money coming in the company which will reduce debts also later six months is weak compare to first 6 months ballpark NP will be close to 400 Crs annualised
We also know post issue the non-promoter holding, including private equity investors and the public, will be 25-26% in the PepsiCo bottler.
Also The CCPSs held by RJ Corp and DHRPL will convert into a maximum of 13,200,845 Equity Shares; the CCDs held by SCPE, AION and ICICI Venture Employees Welfare Trust through IDBI Trusteeship Services Private Limited will convert into a maximum of 26,368,815 Equity Shares, prior to filing of the Red Herring Prospectus with RoC. 771,700 outstanding options granted under ESOS 2013 may be converted into 771,700 Equity Shares prior to filing of the Red Herring Prospectus with RoC.
outstanding Share 135,669,865 Equity Shares per IPO Fresh Issue 15000000 CCDs13200845+26368815+771700 So total outstanding share post IPO will Be 191011225 Shares with NP of 400 Crs will Give a EPS of 21 Aprrox so at 560 it will give PE of of 26.67 which IMO is fair value also given only 10% is available for RII demand will be high
Let see how many CCDs get converted and what is price band
We also know post issue the non-promoter holding, including private equity investors and the public, will be 25-26% in the PepsiCo bottler. Since PE fund r not selling the and issue size is 1400 Crs post IPO hold 13% to 14% stake in 191 million shares so approx 13% to 12% account for 1400 Crs meaning 100% MC should be approx 10769 Crs to 11667 so price band of 560 -610 as per my calculation so at higher end gives it a PE of 29
Which for a FMCG is fair for a top of the line FMCG product line
SO lets see what is actual NP and the real price band IMO it will be a good IPO
Septa ji is right that complete analysis has to wait till new filing of drhp by varun beverages with SEBI. Based on estimates given at http://wp.me/p7zwuc-fQ equity at max can be 190 crore and PE based on dec31 2015 results > 100 though co. has done well in first half year. Perhaps not cheap
32. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
October 9, 2016 12:33:24 AM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 22000+ Likes)
VARUN BEVERAGES
Refer page 104 of the DRHP dated 21 June 2016
As per Restated Consolidated Financial Statements
FY 2013 EPS was (3.10) FY 2014 EPS was (1.51) FY 2015 EPS was 6.46
FY 2013 RONW was (6.70) FY 2014 RONW was (2.66) FY 2015 RONW was 8.00
Interesting to see Varun Beverages venturing into other countries. Varun Beverages has started the construction of its $30 million Pepsi bottling plant in Harare, Zimbabwe
Promoters are getting greedy by seeing the huge response of investors in IPO now a days ... See Endurance ..I am sure some lessons would be learnt ahead ..
Varun is not a bad company but if the pricing is Rs 560 than it is total greed from Promoters .. Can should price between Rs 425-430. Rs 100 is the risk that they are shifting to investors in this IPO taking the fair value of Rs 450-460... Why they are pricing too high ...
They alloted shared on March 31, 2016 @ 150 to employeess ..they can now issue to us at Rs 300 .. As per me their market capitalisation can be max Rs 4000 crores .. lets see