You never did any research. No posting of any analysis or predictions. You don''t have any knowledge. You are always calling good analysts and asking only one thing "my son is CA". I want to say what you are? You are just zero. You are jumping into anyone''s conversation as dog. Stop this stupid thing if you don''t have any knowledge. You don''t have any right to say something to anyone, if you are not able to contribute anything.
Many new members are learning here. Don''t discourage them. They are doing some analysis. Right or wrong is different thing.
1515. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 10:21:35 AM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 21900+ Likes)
Mehulbhai,
Please download the DRHP and read it ... if you cannot find the data you that seek in there … I shall be happy to help.
However, when you keep asking repeatedly for such elementary data that are easily available in the public domain ... it can make you very unpopular (irritating) for other boarders on this forum …
Please grow up … learn to be self dependant ... this matter is about MONEY .. you cannot afford to be so callous about such things …
In the meanwhile, here is to spoon-feed you one more time …
MAHANAGAR GAS LIMITED DRHP dated 21st November 2015 (On Page Nos. 78 & 79)
Eagleye its ROE IS SAME AS RONW 21.36% percent first give me that info ?
1515.4. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 12:07:28 PM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 21900+ Likes)
ROE = Return on Equity & RONW = Return on Net Worth
Unfortunately, I have not had any formal training in Finance as I am an Engineer by qualification ... and as such, I am not aware of the difference between the two ...
However, I hope you being a CA would know if there is any difference between ROE & RONW.
1515.5. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 12:39:26 PM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 21900+ Likes)
I am advised that the Relative Fair Value of Mahanagar Gas is 600-615 ...
That person even tried explaining to me how he calculated it ... But it went tangent over my head.
ITS VERY EASY TAKE IGL ITS ROE IS 20 PERCENT ITS BOOK VALUE 150 SO ITS PRICE AROUND 557 SO ITS BOOK VALUE 150 MULTIPLY BY 4 AS ROE 20 PERCENT IF ROF IS 15 PERCENT THEN MULTIPLY BV BY 3 IN SAME WAY MAHANAGAGR GAS BV166 MULTIPLY BY 4 AS ROE 20 PERCENT SO PRICE RS 664
1515.10. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 1:26:04 PM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 21900+ Likes)
why multiple by 4 if ROE is 20% and multiple by 3 if ROE is 15%
1515.11. Haar Jeet| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 1:28:58 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
i think mehulbhai always trap u in his silly post. asking repeat nd repeat same q.etc which u already answered
IF ROE IS HIGH MEANS EARNINGS AVAILABLE TO SHAREHOLDERS MORE SO ITS PRICE OF SHARE HIGH IF ROE LESS MEANS EARNINGS TO SHAREHOLDERS ARE LESS SO LESSER MULTIPLY
1515.13. Eagleye| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 6:56:56 PM
IPO Guru (6600+ Posts, 21900+ Likes)
Thank you mehulbhai for so patiently explaining to me how you calculate the Fair Value of Mahanagar Gas ... You are so very kind and generous.
Now, can you please also guide me ... what in your opinion should be the listing price of MGL ... and whether does it make sense to apply for the IPO or not .. and if I get any allotment ... at what price should I sell
ITS VERY EASY FOR SMART C.A TO FIND MAHANAGAR GAS IPO FAIR VALUE ITS BASED ON BOOK VALUE AND RONW ITS BEST IPO IT WILL BE ANOTHER THYRO I WILL APPLY WITH DOUBLE FORCE
1510.1. SONMAYA| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 9:50:26 AM
IPO Guru (1300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Dear nehta..to b very frank when expert like ...U....DORY..is there y one. Should learn or bother to find fair value... other boarderers r un necessarily. Taking Pain to find out fair value. ..when. Real.CA.. is there on board.. .........one mire thing when one don''t know how to write....then he has ro Bark.. . Hv a good ...fair value finding Sunday. ...Hey u Dory...
To Sonmaya, You never did any research. No posting of any analysis or predictions. You don''''t have any knowledge. You are always calling good analysts and asking only one thing "my son is CA". I want to say what you are? You are just zero. You are jumping into anyone''''s conversation as dog. Stop this stupid thing if you don''''t have any knowledge. You don''''t have any right to say something to anyone, if you are not able to contribute anything.
Many new members are learning here. Don''''t discourage them. They are doing some analysis. Right or wrong is different thing.
1510.6. SONMAYA| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 11:54:22 AM
IPO Guru (1300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
At the age of 69..I don''t really require anything my dear so called D.Pandey....new enterent...with fake id....I know who u r. This is yr first message here in this board....and u says u r learning.... that''s fine I think u r invisible.. And u r right I don''t know anyrhing...my dear XYZ. .???
Sonmaya, Now you don''t know that I am old on this board. I am not a frequent contributor but posting messages since last 9 months. You provided one another proof that you don''t know how to find any member''s past history in this board. Another time you proved that you are just a barking dog.
I am fully agree to Mehul Mehta. You don''t know English also. Writing messages with many commas etc. I suggest you to learn English first. Financial analysis is not a piece of cake for you at the age of 69. If you learn English and how to respect anyone''s analysis is enough for you.
1509. CLD| Link| Bookmark|
May 8, 2016 7:56:59 AM
Top Contributor (500+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
I would like to know which of the following banks do not generate OTP to complete application submission in ASBA mode.
SBI, PNB, AXIS BANK.
This is important for me since I will be out of country for about 2 months where I will not be able to receive OTP on my registered mobile.
Hi CLD, Sbi and Axisbank asks for OTP. PNB I don''t know. But I also travel a lot outside India and whenever I need I switch on my Indian SIM to get the OTP and then after I again switch off the SIM. Most of the smart phone has this SIM switchoff/on mode.
It works fine. I have done it many time from UK, Europe, Middle East and south east Asia.
If u can tell me where r u travelling probably I can help u more.
Can Zerodha account be used to apply for IPO, buying shares from BSE/NSE to hold long term i.e. not to trade/intraday? If so, what are the advantages/disadvantages of having account with these guys instead of Icici direct, Sharekhan etc? Please provide unbiased opinion so I can make decision about opening account with them.
I am so SAD...... over the SUN kind of feeling..... DORY is not going to ask me any more question so drown in sorrow i am heading to Cream stone to mourn my loss of knowledge
Dear Septa Ji, Can you tell me the ex dividend date of INTERGLOBE AVI. I have purchased Indigo at an avg price of 865 Qty-250, having around 50 K profit. Should I sell some or any target you can assign.
Official announcement Dividend29-Apr-2016InterGlobe Aviation Limited has informed the Exchange that the Board of Directors of the Company at its meeting held on April 29, 2016 have recommended a final dividend of Rs.15 per share (face value of Rs.10 per share) for the financial year ended March 31, 2016, subject to the approval of shareholders in the upcoming Annual General Meeting.