Steel City Securities Ltd IPO Message Board (Page 1)

IPO Analysis, take the moral responsibility for the loss incurred by some of the investors in Steelcity on account of your negative posts on and just after listing.
Who gives wrong advice is clear now, so I am not commenting on it.
Who requires more knowledge in stock market you decide?
Steelcity in its half month of listing touched Rs.75.75, a return of 38% apprx.
Moreover, yesterday in its Board meeting it has announced R''s.1 dividend per share.

My only request to you is that don''t post anything negative on any company just before the date of listing, on the day of listing and immediately after listing. If anyone has taken a bet, let him try his luck.

Best of luck, dear investors.
You may refer various sources of information but take final decision on your own.

u know steel city ki delivery kaise lagani hai

means market type = normal ya kaise?


sme ki delivery kaise lagti hai?

IF YOU LOOK PAST HISTORY OF SME STOCK BROKERS HAVE NOT PERFORMED WELL . EVEN WEALTH SME WHICH CAME RECENTLY HAVE NOT DONE WELL
THERE IS GREAT CHANCE OF THESE COMPANIES LISTING AT DISCOUNT

IF U LLOK AT MY PAST RECOMMENDATION I AHVE ADVISED PEOPLE TO BUY AMBITION MICA,JIYA ECOPRODUCTS,LANCER CONTAINER,LOYAL,HITECH,FOURTH,JET FREIGHT WHEN THEY WERE AVAILABLE AT SUCH GOOD PRICE AND HAVE GOOD BUSINESS MODEL

wt was yr reco..fr..DRA......please..write...here..

steel city is now at 64


now say

NPT UR RECOMMENDATION FOR DEBT FREE COMPANY STEEL SECURITIES IS DOING VERY WELL.

PLEASE KEEP ADDING MORE STOCK OF THIS COMPANY IF YOU ARE SO CONFIDENT OF THIS COMPANY. STOCK IS ALREADY DOWN 12 PC AND WOULD BE DOWN MORE THAN 50 PC IN 6 MONTHS TIME
U R NOT AWARE THAT NOT A SINGLE SME OF KEYNOTE HAS PERFORMED IN MARKET
PLEASE GO AND GAIN SOME KNOWLEDGE IN MARKET BEFORE COMMENTING AND AVDICING PEOPLE TO HOLD WRONG SCRIPS.

also point to be noted is Keynote few issues which have given returns too listed at discount on opening day.

So keynote have bad records both for short term and long term issues.
NPT f u r confident of Keynote issues please buy all there shares as most of them ar at huge discounts. i have given the list. please go ahead and purchase them as u look overconfident

What about HEM securities as a lead manager.
Give your views

On the listing day i.e. on 17th Feb. 19.06 lacs shares of Steel City Securities are traded out of which 13.66 lacs shares i.e. 72% of the total trade is deliverable trades.
To me, it shows that there is good demand for the share in the market.
Take the decision as per your own prudence.
Good luck.

My dear IPO analysis, here is my response to some of your posts:
1. You had posted on 24 Nov 2016 in jet freight that the lead manager has come with another expensive ipo i.e. Jet Freight Logistics, appealed to all of us to boycott it as the fair value in your opinion was R''s.7-10.
My dear today it is trading at 79.80.
When you saw that the price is increasing in the market you started everyone to buy it and now claiming that you had recommendation.
2. Maheswari Logistics paper business is new and would incur loss, would be battered heavily. Your post DT.12th Feb.
The share has still given positive return to the investors with highest price reaching 82 since listing and not heavily battered till now.
There are so many good companies like ICICI prudential life, mcx, L&t info, etc even rated extremely good by capital market, still gave initial loss to the investors.
3. On Feb 03, you had mentioned that bse is reaching 2000, see the price after your post. One should not claim that he/she is a market pundit. Let others say that you are a market pundit just like as investors praise eagleye, septa, etc.
4. On Jan 9 you had given a comment on Profile Industries that it would reach 22in a few days.
Now it is ready 41.
5. Your comment no.29 on the same day that Libas to reach 45.
Now it is trading at 68.
6. You have given comments that Key note is not reliable due to poor performance of some of the IPOs shares managed by this company in the recent past.
I have verified it and found that some of the IPOs managed by keynote is not doing well. However, there are a large number of shares managed by keynotes in the past are performing very well and a few have moved to Main stream also.
Even there are a large number of reputed Registrars like Link times, etc their all the companies are not performing well.
My request to all that it is not possible so many data, information here due to typing difficulties. They may click on the name of the IPO Registrar>Report you will find the detail IPOs managed by the Registrar, find the present price from the bse/bse sites and make your own assessment.
Remember investors have list money even in mcx, ICICI prudential, quick heal, etc where the lead managers were the reputed ones.
In the past I have also suffered loss where Karvy was the Registrar/Lead manager.
7. Another request to you, Sir is that till the last date of the subscription if anyone has any negative opinion, they may post. And inspite of this anyone has taken a call let him take the risk.
My appeal is that at least just before or on the date of listing don''t post anything negative about the issue as it may spoil the sentiments of the market as well as the investors which may be damaging.
Regarding steel city securities my opinion is that the management is good, experienced, highly qualified. They are very much compliance oriented of different rules, laws of the regulator which may be observed from their tax payments history.
The stock has every chance to move to the main stream.
Chittirgarh.com is nicely facilitating it''s visitors and investors by providing review by Dilip Davda, an experienced analyst. Take the decision on your own analysis and risk taking appetite.
Have a good day.

Dear NpT

Have you looked at my recommended SME stocks carefully which ahve given multibagger returns.

Buy Lancer container,loyal equipments,jiya ecoproducts,hitech pipes,universal auto,fourth dimension,

this was when they were available at very cheap price and now have doubled and even gone 10 times

this shows u r fool not to look at my 20 correct recommendation earlier.

stop folling urself as i have made great returns from sme

ur recent post shows u have no knowledge and my correct recommendation of steel securities have hurt u as u were asking everyone not to sell whereas all people are now in loss in steel securities whether they are trader or investors.

please go ahead cry baby as i know u have incurred huge losses in steel securities







on''''t sell SCSL in panic.
No body knows how the market will react.
Fair value of the issue price is calculated as per sebi guidelines and I guess that it can''''t be manipulated by 100% increase.
I have strong belief that it will perform upto the expectations of the investors.

9.1. R GARG Feb 15, 2017 6:02:24 PM IST
Steel City Securities Ltd IPO

Company is good. Few things about steel city.
1. Zero debt company,
2. Dividend paying company from last fine years,
3. Gst no. Will be required for all traders n service provider so huge scope for future business
4. Companies turn over is less than 50 cr. So immediate gain of 5 percent in corporate tax, so company ''''s PE will improve

Stop spreading lies NpT . i know u have suffered huge losses in steel securities and would incur more losses.

I have full sympathy with u . u have been proven wrong with all ur statements.

I have never said not to apply jet freight. stop spreading false news and show me the comment
Infact i have been positive on this company and have advised everyone to keep adding more stocks of it

IPOANALYSIS Jan 16, 2017 11:01:18 AM IST | 1 | Reply
Sell maheswari as it''''''''s paper business is new and wd incur losses. Would be battered heavily in time to come. Management also is not trsutworthy Instead go and buy jet freight logistics which earn revenues from domestic and international airline freight and also going to enter shipping sector soon



12. IPOANALYSIS Dec 22, 2016 8:16:56 PM IST Reply
Veeram Ornaments Ltd IPO

hhahaha

please apply and get your money halved in 10 days only

jewellery stocks have been battered in this market.




9. IPOANALYSIS Dec 16, 2016 12:50:47 AM IST Reply
Laurus Labs Ltd IPO

this will be a slow and steady mover. should keep this for long term.

another DR lal path,advance enzyme,thyrocare ,syngene type of story.
do remember those who sold above stocks on listing still repent and made mistakes

sit tight and hold for long term gains in this stock.
avatar
8. IPOANALYSIS Dec 14, 2016 1:48:02 PM IST Reply
Sheela Foam Ltd IPO

All weak hand retailers are almost out.stock in strong hands headed towards 1350 in short term

Respected Admin, Chittorgarh.Com,
Yesterday there was a post from IPOAnalysis in which they had commented, "Jo humse lega......". I think that in the same post they had also given comment on Jer Freight share performance.
I request you to please re-post the message as I would like to reply to the post. You may delete some part of the message if you feel so but their comment on Jet freight may be re-posted to respond it.

I got that post and I will respond to it on Monday i.e. on 20th Feb at 7.30 a.m.

A special round of thanks to IPOanalysis ji, for his guidance.
After seeing your analysis , i did not apply for it ..
:)

I was reading the comment of IPOANALYSIS and full credit to you Sir...throughout the posts for Steel City you have been warning investors regarding listing gain which there never was today. Also spot on regarding Keynote registrar....Great work Sir, its members like you that bring me to this site.

when i said keynote is a bad lead manager everybody said what is the difference its going to make in listing price

now hope they got answer for keynote listed sme and would stay away from them

Very good Analysis

IPO Analysis, give your opinion on the forthcoming sme IPOs too.
Investment decision is upto the investors.
But, one suggestion from my side is that when someone has invested in any sme IPOs inspite of some concerns he should wait for some time or should not apply at all.
Their nervousness and panic sells is creating adverse impact on the listing price and on the other investors.
Those who cannot absorb loss in sme IPOs should avoid applying.
Today more than 19 lacs shares of steel city were traded, still closing at R''s.51 and above the lowest price of the day.
Hope Monday would be a good day for the investors.
Best of luck.

Those who have invested in Steelcity Security new that it is sme and listing risk was not ignored that means investors were ready to accept lower listing of 10-20% also.
If you were risk taking then why to sell in loss.
Moreover, around 20% i.e.890000 shares have been bought which to me is that the share has demand.
I feel that those who are buying are also informed investors.

opened down. will hit lower circuit in next few days, get out of this crap.

I told everyone its a bad stock. noone listened. same with maheshwari which went down after listing

55. IPOANALYSIS Feb 15, 2017 3:54:10 PM IST | I Like It. 1 | Report Abuse Reply
This stock will be hammered. Keynote is worst lead manager.plz chk performance of all its sme. Pathetic performance. Expect heavy selling on listing day will take this below issue price.plz exit if given any chance. Never keep any keynote sme for long term. Fair value of stock is 20 rs

Dear where did you find the stock price, i cant see it.

Good stock for long term, Can expect 50% returns within next 6months time frame. So dont rush for listing gains. May be you can offload 30% of shares and keep remaining 70% to take advantage of Listing gains

DEAR AKMP,
Thanks and i agree if you have only 1 stock you have to sell FULL. Am adviciing for people who have more than 1 lot :-) I have 4 lots

Congrats for 4 lot now it is available in 52 now you can add more what ever qty you like
but do''t make foolish to other peoples

Listing kitne baje hoygi aj

9.15am

Hi my dear investors tommorow on Friday 17th Feb 2017 steelcity securities Ltd listing.Basic information about this company EPS 49.50 continously dividend paying company ,largest organization in E-governance and Basic platform stock broking from last two decades.In bidding retailers partispation 6.74 times and HNI Part 3.19 times.definately huge returns will get on listing and long term no need to worry.

rs 1.63/- dividend
rs 50730 crore turnover
brokerage earning rs 20 crore

fair value rs 80/- on 20 PE

4th quarter result will be excellent due to improvement in the stock market.

15 rs gmp

Ready to sell four lots

What price I should sell for only listing gains?? As you are saying 15rs in GM.. So will it be around 68-70??

What is the grey market price?

Listing kal h Friday ko
Best of luck for all allotted people

Steel city ka premium kitna he