Shree Ganesh Jewellery House Ltd IPO Message Board (Page 2)

1036. Anil

Following is the facts about your Shree Ganesh Calls: -

Read Post # 974, 920, 908 & 879.

You are pointing only your success rates. I am pointing both my success & failure. That is the difference.

To your criticism list, add DB Corp also. I have not applied thinking it is over-valued. Hence, missed listing gain.

Except my call about Hathway & Indiabulls all fundamental calls clicked.

Regarding technical calls, I am giving time-to-time even intra-day also.

SJVN

Fundamental call valid. When it has Rs.13 upside (Rs.38), why don't you hold till it breaches Rs.20. It is good long-term investment. Fundamentally, nobody can guess whether it gives listing gain or not.

Regarding technicals, my call is still open.

Indiabulls Power

Lost Rs.12,500 within minutes.

Hathway

Lost at opening bell. But made net-profit at closing by shorting.

Nobody can guess 100% correctly. Your Mandhana call went wrong. You have criticised my comments about Mandhana. Now who is fool?

I have four years experience in trading & I am investor since eight years. I have lost Rs.1 lac subscribing to intra-day calls by seeing advertisements in Business Line, Economic Times, web-sites like "ValueNotes" etc.

I understsmd very well pitfalls of intra-day trading. Numberous trades, wrong-signals in charts, high transactions costs, small profits, big risks, holding our nerves - totally dyes are heavily cast against day-trader. It is a big story.

I will share my view regarding how & when both technicals & fundamentals will fail? No wonder, 95% intra-day traders are loosers.

Of course, I have some failures. When I know perfect formula for 100% success, then I will stop working.

Ravi, Bangalore,
At the same time don't stop giving your opinions as people like me value them and follow them whenever we want.

Ravi, Bangalore,
I fully agree with you. He remained silent on the days this share went up. But in my opinion the best reply to him is to ignore him. Please do that and don't take up any challenges with him.

1037. K.K.Natarajan

Read Anil's Post # 1025.

Earlier he was telling Shree Ganesh will fall to Rs.35. It is fraud company etc. Investors were panic. He was continuosly asking people to short-sell daily.

Some Board Members have even objected for his comments and pointed-out that his calls have failed (if you see previos pages in this web-page, you can notice that). Board Members who regulaly read this page know that very well.

I have only given my opinion. What is his problem to comment with wrong facts? It is just my view & Board Members should view in that way. In addition, it is only IPO forum & discussing only about IPOs are wel-come. Whether anybody follows or ignores is left to them. I don't have any benefit if they make profit / loss. I am not getting any moneytary benefit & Anil is not my paid client to talk.

Ravi, Bangalore & Anil
We know Ravi is knowledgeable. Anil may also be so. You both may have disputes and your own egos, as do all others have. In a public forum giving healthy challenges and having healthy disputes is welcome. But, for heaven's sake, why do you call one another fool? Don't forget that nobody - be it Ravi, Bangalore or Anil - forces anybody to buy or sell as per his view. To follow or not is the individuals concern. Stop fighting and give healthy challenges, please!

Ravi Bangalore when you say facts please check earlier comments on this forum and bring back facts that my calls for shree ganesh has failed.

infact i have given call 10 times in this forum to short and it was correct 9 times so success ratio is 90%

whereas all ur calls whether its sjvnl, hathway,indiabulls power all were incorrect . give me ur correct recommendation ever.even today shree ganesh has dripped down. will you blacken ur face if it falls below 110 rs.

when you say apply in SJVNL you are a big fool. no one earned money in this stock even with 5% discount to retailers. when i can easily get this stock available at 24 rs now why should anyone apply at 24.70 and sit on loss when he can easily get below issue price . check my recommendation of sjvnl also in ipo recommendation.

you are a big fool you have proved once again

1028. ANIL

Hathway - I had given fundamentally BUY. But when it cracked issue price, immediately sold & given SELL call technically.

Shree Ganesh - Both fundamentally & technically SELL call last month. This month, BUY in 110 -130. That is still valid.

INDIABULLS POWER - Fundamentally BUY. But sold as soon as it breached issue price & booked loss. I had not given any technical call in this forum.

SJVN- Fundamentally BUY. But technically wait for appropriate level to enter. You better check-up this call which is still available to see for everybody.

Now, it is confirmed that Bigger Fool Theory applies to you. When you are blaming others, point-out facts. Don't blame in general & don't talk in air.

1031. Anil

I accept your challenge. You give 4 stocks, for same stocks I give my opinion openly in this forum (stop-loss & targets may change, even direction of stock may change).

You must understand that medium-term investors make money compared to intra-day traders.

1028. ANIL

Can you tell which call that I have given has failed? Don't talk in air. Point-out specifically and tell.

Meanwhile, can you please give your tips for 10 consecutive days? At the end of 10 trades, can a trader make profit following your calls?

Your Shree Ganesh intra-day calls that you had given last month have flopped. Proof is available if you go back in this web-page itself.

Only my fundamental call on Hathway failed. But still I believe its fair value is Rs.390 & it will not disappoint for long-term investors. It is oldest cable operator & definitely it has business potential.

Intra-day is not fools game. But the way you advise, I think you are one bigger fool. How can you short everyday Shree Ganesh?

Missed 1 BUY Lakshmi Vilas Bank at 79.75 with target of 92 rs stop loss 76 rs ( 1 week)

Ravi Please give ur 4 stocks for 1 week and lets see who is better

Please remember below are not intraday calls but for 1 week holding

BUY Calls

Buy united bank at 78 with target of 84
Buy Alembic at 45.50 with target of 50
Buy rei agro at 43.40 with target of 49
Buy IL&fs trasnport at 278 with target of 300

Ravi you are stupid fool and only have bookish knowledge from where you write.you think yourself as very intelligent and think of technical patterns whereas in market it does not follow any pattern.

all your advice i have been saying have been an utter flop
consider buying hathway,shree ganesh,indiabulls power and sjvnl all are down.

you should shut ur mouth now and not write rubbish things.

For ur information i was replying and giving answer to person who asked aht price i short

if you think intrday is fools game you are then biggest fool giving advice then why that traget of stop loss advice to buy was that long term call for stop loss.

at first i thought you were intelligent but now i know you are bigget fool in this forum.

1025. Anil

INTRADAY TRADING - A Fools Game

Day-trading is for "fools" and that it is very difficult to make a living from Day Trading.

It is never easy to make money. Good traders have many years of experience behind them. For every successful trader there has probably been a few hundred who have tried and failed.

I would say that for the aspiring intra-day trader, trading is a fool's game.

In case you are successful intra-day trader, give 10 days free-trial. Post your trading calls in this forum for 10 consecutive trading days. Then, we will come to know what kind of intra-day trader you are.

1025. Anil

I have suggested buy for long-term investors in 110-130 range with stop-loss. Not for short-term trading.

Why you are saying @ 2:45 that you have shorted? Why did not you tell the same in the morning? Market has fallen & after watching you are saying that you have shorted.

No wonder, many of your intra-day trading tips have flopped. You tell 10 tips, out of that, 6 - 7 will flop. After netting to brokerage, intra-day traders who trade on your tips will loose more than they gain. Even your hit rate is 50% (actually, your intra-day tips have 30% hit rate), traders will loose.

SEE RAVI, BANGALORE YOU ASKED TO BUY THIS AT 128 AND CHECK THE PRICE TODAY.

I HAVE SHORT THIS STOCK IN MORNINING ITSELF AT 124.20 AND NOW ITS 118.HAHAHAHA

HOPE IT GOES DOWN 100 SOON

@ anil

aaj kitne pe short kiya hai apne ??

@ Ravi,

Good one. Will write it in my book(remembering Nana in Bluff master). Anyways i do agree with that philosophy. And with this one also:" Fundamentals guide the future of a stock. So if you are an investor and believe in a script, hold onto it". In the words of Rakesh Jhunjhunwala:
A). " I've the right to be wrong"
B). "Invest right and hold tight"

INVESTMENT WORLD

Once upon a time a man told a small village, “I will buy monkeys for Rs.100 each.”

Since there were many monkeys in the forest, the villagers caught them and sold them to the man.

As the supply of monkeys diminished, the villagers’ efforts slowed, so the man offered them Rs.200 each.

They renewed their efforts but the supply of monkeys diminished further, so he increased his price to Rs.500.

Soon no one could even find a monkey in the forest.

The man increased his price to Rs.1000, but announced, “Since I must go to the city on business, I authorize my assistant to buy monkeys on my behalf.”

As soon as his boss was gone, the assistant told the villagers, “My boss has collected lots of monkeys. I’ll sell them to you for Rs.2,000 and then, when he returns, you can sell them to him for Rs.3,000.”

The villagers rounded up all the money they could and bought as many monkeys as possible. Then they had monkeys everywhere…

… but they never saw the man or his assistant again.

And now you understand the workings of the stock market!