Shalby Limited IPO Message Board (Page 9)

GMP last heard:

Shalby IPO
6.50 - 7.50

*SHALBY LIMITED*
FINAL SUBS.FIGURE AT 11:59 P.M.
QIB 4.47X**
NII 0.43X
RII 3.01X
EMP 1.44X
TOTAL 2.86X
**Excluding Anchor
Total No.of FORMS : 319433
*Apps Wise : 2.71X*
*STATUS-CLOSED*

Believe only those expert who says apply or avoid before subscription open,
After subscription/last day there is no need to shout i have applied/not applied due to subscription figures

Are bhai india me 75% log offline /through broker application karte hai, so they have to submit there applications on 2nd day itself or morning last day and you say apply /avoid 2/3pm ,haha

Andhe ko bhi pata lagta hai ki nii<1x ,qib<5x hua to listing gain nahi milne wala,
Usme aap ne kya badi bat kr di ??

If you are real expert then say before ipo opens otherwise no need to give any justification of apply/avoid

Are bhai, intraday trader ho kya?
Aaj buyers jyada hai to buy, warna sell??

@KING VINOD
What your view on Shalby ipo.

@KING VINOD
What your view on Future Supply ipo?

I Not applied Shalby Limited IPO.
I am Not applying Future Supply IPO.
I am Applying Astron paper IPO
Must Apply Astron Paper & Board Mill Ltd IPO

Due to absence of market valuation and trading history of the stock, investing in an IPO is inherently much riskier than investing in Secondary market.

Investors should be additionally cautious, while investing in any IPO where there is no reasonable assurance of at least 10% return and they should think multiple times why they want to invest when expected listing gains are not even 10%.

It will be another HDFC and Sheela form, avoiders regrets

@Anarchist: Now according to that, with HDFC and ICICI Pru in opposite directions, Sheela must be the Insurance agent standing in the middle (of nowhere)...!!!

True that.....things have reached a point where only satire can make sense...

Final Subscription
===============
Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIB) ---------- 4.34x
Non Institutional Investors (NII) --------------- 0.42x
Retail Individual Investors(RII) ---------------- 2.98x
Employee Reserved (EMP) ------------------- 1.44x

Total ----------------------------------------------- 2.82x

No.of Applications (Approx) ------------ 319433
Retail Applicationwise (Approx) --------- 2.71x

Shalby Ltd. IPO:
Subscription figures on last day @4pm (BSE+NSE):-
QIB - 4.34X** (closed)
HNI - 0.424X (closed)
Retail - 2.54X (open only for offline form)
Employees - 1.29X (open only for offline form)
Total - 2.61X
**Excluding Anchor.
Not so encouraging figures. I have not applied.

2.7 times subscribed Applications wise

Not only subscription figure, but brand, Management, and most importantly instict plays important role for applying decision. I would say all points towards avoid.

I have NOT applied after tracking forums here, reading various analysis, news, sentiments and even last moment subscription figures @ 2PM were dismal, with not enough QIB/HNI participation. Employee quota subscription looked overzealous and fabricated, even I have doubt over their brand power as well as financials!

Those who are guessing this listing would be a dark horse, only time will tell, but I went with my convictions, will apply for Future Supply tomorrow instead... your views appreciated.

It will list on 350 above on listing day
So don''t worry

Really? You think so? No HNI/QIB demand...

*SHALBY LIMITED*
FINAL DAY SUBS.FIGURE AT 05:35 P.M.
QIB 4.47X**
NII 0.43X
RII 2.70X
EMP 1.32X
TOTAL 2.71X
**Excluding Anchor
Total No.of FORMS : 2,84,228
*Apps Wise : 2.41X*

Ahmedabad company, Speculative promotor and employee subscription figure ( which is amazingly more than one time) indicates high volatility will remain in this script. I don''t expect flat opening or 8 to 10 rs premium, it would go either of any side with big margin. Let''s c after Hdfc what does have to teach us this time.

I have read the RHP once i reached page 160 i stop reading and going ahead and applying this IPO. presently out 9 hospital only 2 big hospital and one small are a mature cycle. The rest 6 in if infancy stage(new hospital) plus another 3 green shot hospital project.... So from here revenue will grow bcoz it takes at least 3 to 5 years for a hospital to give positive EBITA.....

Will it give listing gain: yes very less 4% to 12% depending on market condition on listing at the fair price is around 220 at 25% MOS so listing will be in range of Rs 220 to Rs.280

presently i am more interested in applying pre IPO in Hero finance, NSE, TMB, CSB so will be busy reading offer documents from these pre IPO

With regards to Future logistic apply for listing gain good business model with GST and infra status

Lesson to be learnt
Never jump to conclusions before reading full pages

Dear Septa Sir,

We really need your guidance & support in this market turbulence..

Share information if you are available on any other kind of communication modes like twitter etc. to guide small retail investors.

Regards,
Nilesh

AVOID

Subscription @04.00pm
==================
Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIB) ---------- 4.34x (Closed)
Non Institutional Investors (NII) --------------- 0.43x (Closed)
Retail Individual Investors(RII) ---------------- 2.46x
Employee Reserved (EMP) ------------------- 1.29x

Total ----------------------------------------------- 2.56x

No.of Applications (Approx) ------------ 259178
Retail Applicationwise (Approx) --------- 2.20x

As valuation is very low i am expecting 15 to 20 percentage return.

go for short term gain

***Avoid****

This will loot u this will koot u!!!!

FY. 2017 Financial all crooked
PBT 53cr
PAT 62cr.... Simply amazing!!!

Total debt 409cr @10%p.a.interst
Interest paid 10cr... Wow!!!!

Actually PBT 53cr - 30cr interest capitalised =23cr Actual PBT
less Income tax mean
actual PAT 15cr only
So EPS less than 2
PE 125

In IPO one should have compelling reason to invest otherwise there r more than enough stocks to bet for short term return.
Here i m not sure either the price nor quality of the issue.... Then why invest???

Get out if allotted
No fundamental reason to hold on.

Subscription @03.40pm
==================
Qualified Institutional Buyers (QIB) ---------- 4.34x
Non Institutional Investors (NII) --------------- 0.30x
Retail Individual Investors(RII) ---------------- 2.39x
Employee Reserved (EMP) ------------------- 1.26x

Total ----------------------------------------------- 2.50x

No.of Applications (Approx) ------------ 251416
Retail Applicationwise (Approx) --------- 2.13x

Shelby IPO will move in the pattern of HDFC, life.Those, who have decide to avoid will repent

It will not........

HDFC kaha Shalby kahan? HDFC has a 20-year record of creating wealth across group companies. Too much uncertainty in the market. Better to err on the side of caution/

QIB 2.62
HNI 0.03
RETAIL1.40
TOTAL 1.45
APPLICATION WISE 1.23 TIMES
AT 12.45PM

Does anyone think it will hit 3x in total atleast?

3X will not matter anyways......