Mukka Proteins Limited IPO Message Board (Page 31)

​@ValueSeeker I've gone with 71 lots x5, just to try something new

Bhai cbi wale raid daldenge tumare ghar pe

67 lots or 100 lots same chance of allotment

​@rohiitian bhai, won't that be a rather odd number? Round figure like 70 could be safer, nahi?

​@ValueSeeker I've seen a few BOAs, generally upto 75 lots is safe, and quite often 71 has better probability than others. Hence taking a chance.

Min BHNi lots is always safer and guarantee for inclusion in the lottery. I am personally going with 2x stage 10 (67+10) for riskier one for a try with less rush slot.
Stage 10: Courtesy @DEVBULL

​@CB☺ 
This time I have applied for 2 x 72 lots (6th stage from Bhni(Mim)

दोनों फॉर्म्स 77 वाली में आवंटन नही हुआ। अब बस अजगर (BOA) का अवलोकन (पोस्टमार्टम) करना बचा है।
​@DEVBULL , आपको आवंटन हुआ या नहीं 72 वाली फॉर्म्स में?

My choice was 77lots: Stage 10(+) and it was good choice. Still not lucky enough:
67 Lots: Ratio = 47.12 (45571/967)
71 Lots: Ratio = 43.33 (130/3)
76 Lots: Ratio = 61 (61/1)
77 Lots: Ratio = 36.5 (73/2)

किसी तरह जुगाड़ कर के 5-6 रिटेल एप्लिकेशंस (1 लॉट वाली) लगती है और आप लोग 77-100 लॉट x 4 की बात कर रहे हो।
मैं कब पहुँचुंगा इस लेवल तक, ईश्वर जाने।

​@DEVBULL @GrayIsTheNewBlack Mukka is a rare Mainboard IPO where the BOA is not on sample basis. But not able to understand one thing

There are many lotsizes with just 13-14-15 applications and they all went to lottery, even though this was oversubscribed 50x in BHNI. I thought a lotsize only entered lottery if >50% of subscription (so in this case 25 lots of more). What am I misunderstanding?

​@rohiitian , after the allotment to categories with (applications > 50% of overall subscriptions) if there are any leftover lots, they will get further distributed into lower categories as well (in descending order).
I would say these allottees were extremely lucky as there were many left over lots and in this case allotment went down to as low as 13 !!!
It is always better to apply for lot sizes where you will find sufficient number of fellow applicants to be on the safe side.

​ @GrayIsTheNewBlack Ah makes sense thanks!

​@GrayIsTheNewBlack I hv a doubt . If suppose any mainline issue is say subscribed 70 times in bhni and if I used to apply 10 BhNI application then is it better to apply for higher lot like 68 to 74 to get at least one confirmed allotment. Is it so in Mainboard IPO. Pl give how it works as u gave hints In sme earlier ..... . Also is there any chances of allotment of 272 lots in sona sme ....which was subscribed 555 times in NIN category.

​@PLAZA Sir, I'm assuming when you say 70x it is amount wise and not application wise.
Application wise oversubscription in this case will be ~ 14x
Lets say you apply 10 applications of 75 lots and if you are alone in that category, you will definitely get one lot of allotment.
But, usually I've seen there are multiple applicants even 68,69,...70+ lots.
We cannot say at the time of application, if there won't be any other applicant at that lot size (to guarantee one allotment from our 10 applications).
In general the higher the lot size you go with your 10 bHNI applications higher is the chance of you being the solo applicant (with your 10 applications).

For 272 lot application in Sona, I think you do have very good chance of allotment (if you are the sole applicant at 272 lots)
I guess from 555x, few applications may get rejected on technical grounds bringing the oversubscription figure slightly lower.

​@GrayIsTheNewBlack Thank you very much for giving your views on Bhni application and so no need to apply on higher lot if subscription is too high and it is better to apply for smallest lot for Bhni . As I hv not gone throgh of any BOA OF MAINLINE ipo till now but from.this forum came to know that this happens in Main line also like sme so wanted to know the mechanism ....
What I understand if any issue say subscribe more then 200 times in Bhni amount wise then we can think for appx 140 lots of 10 application to get one assured allotment if no other applicant there in that lot .. is it so.. Pl update if I m wrong...or so ...txs

​@GrayIsTheNewBlack Further what I presumed in sona cast if any one applied for 270or 271 lots and allotted by considering excess carried forward shares than chance of allotment in 272 will be less if exclusive one application .As I presumed it for 500 to 520 and applied for 272 but by 3.33 pm to 3.50 pm it crossed from 450 to 550...

Valid

Aap jab check kroge allotment to 2 bid dikhayega that's the problem in shni.....🙏

Valid, no need to worry

Avoided this one

Not applied

​@MVP  Sir, if you think that subscription is very low..kindly help me to get just 3 retail allotment..it will be great help from your side. Why are we ignoring such good subscription despite pure negativity surrounding this ipo amid veg/non veg debate?

​@Simply Vicky  Have you read what I said? Or replied just to play smart and troll?
Comprehension problem seems.

well said @MVP