As i said i am not going to even think to sell below @90 .. Bcoz today is difficult, tomorrow is more difficult but day after tomorrow is beautiful and post people and their patience die on tomorrow evening..
552.4. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 31, 2023 4:55:10 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
All the very best… Let’s hope upward journey of Chaman starts with a bang! 👍👍
552.5. Imhilli| Link| Bookmark|
January 31, 2023 9:17:09 AM
IPO Guru (1200+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
Volume is reducing because everyday it is seeing new low and people are wishing to buy at lower price. This stock has potential to become multi bagger and sellers should realise that. Now who ever is selling, doing that with a good amount of loss. Once there is a shortage of supply, price is bound to swing back.
551. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 30, 2023 12:07:51 PM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
24.21 Cr issue. Thoda time lega maal corner hone me.. Tabhi chalega, jab mostly log thak ke baith jayenge aur koi track nahii kar raha hoga.. :)
respected senior members i cannot understand company is in expansion phase despite all the positives why it cannot find buyers at this valuation which seems reasonable
Thinking to add one more by monday or Tuesday if prices available at 50-54
548. GuruMahadev| Link| Bookmark|
January 27, 2023 12:46:32 PM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
Holding 3 units average price at 64 for long term. Thanks for the guidance... All senior members(SSingh Sir, Mravi Sir, Lokes Sir & Noorul Sir)
547. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 25, 2023 11:16:47 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
Chaman has informed NSE on 25.01.2023 evening that it has bagged an order worth Rs.14.88 Cr. from Beekay Engineering Corporation to be completed within 1 year.
547.1. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 6:15:42 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
If we give 2-3 years to Chaman then it can easily give 3X-5X returns… Looks the best bet amongst recently listed companies. Fingers crossed 🤞🤞
547.2. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 7:34:26 AM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@SSingh It reminds me of Insolation Energy which regularly updates exchange regarding work orders etc and stock has performed exceedingly well and infact became multibagger. I sold it recently and entered in Chaman after listing as I didn't get allotment. Hope, it performs as expected by you. 👍🙏
Chaman has awarded order to beekay and not bagged order, pls rectify
547.4. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 8:02:28 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Yes. They have given order to build their manufacturing plant after getting approval from env ministry.
547.5. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 8:47:58 AM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@AshishTheBoss Yes, you have rightly pointed out my mistake but I can't withdraw my post. So it may please be read accordingly. Thank God, I attached the letter of Chaman. 😇🙏
547.6. arvindarvind| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 11:36:22 AM
Top Contributor (900+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Now its is a great news. Now this share will become rocket. Enjoy those who are holding.
All the new members that have just joined Chittorgarh forum. Please stop blaming and criticizing all the senior members. They are only helping us by providing their opinion or advice. They are not obligated in any way nor owe us anything,by blaming them you are deterring them from giving their opinions/advice. This is a very healthy forum and has been nothing but helpful. They are anyways going to put their money where they find great valuation and conviction. We need them, it's not the other way around! Smes'are already very risky and unpredictable segment. You aren't going to get any information regarding Smes' anywhere else. At the end of the day it's your money and your decision,so don't blame anyone else for it. I am also a newbie in Sme segment as well as in the forum.
Really sorry to all the senior members from my side @SSINGH sir @Noorul sir @Mravi sir @Gaurav DD Dimer sir @Trueinfo sir @ipo share sir @imhilli sir.
546.1. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 25, 2023 6:46:17 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@Mr.Investor Thanks for your concern but I think it is a healthy discussion and there seems to be nothing wrong in it. As you have rightly pointed out, this Chittorgarh is a great blessing for SME Investors as no other forum can provide such valuable guidance fro very senior members/experts who themselves are big HNIs and are humble enoto share their strategies. I also express my gratitude to the likes of @MRavi, Noorul, lokes Sir for their continues help 🙏
@Mravi sir, @Noorul and Dear experts, There has been lot of positive news about this company. However, stock is not performing that strongly even after buying from Hem. I am holding 2 lots bought at 60.. what's your view on further progress of this share in short term?
Thanks @SSingh, I could see many conversations on holding it for long. But short term targets are blurry. Many experts showed it to be exploding after LC reversal, which didn't happen. Hence I am little concerned on the short term. Long term is definitely bright.
545.3. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 25, 2023 12:58:48 PM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Bhai SHORT term me OPERATOR chalate hain SME IPOs ko... Medium and Long term me Company ki PERFORMANCE... We can't predict OPERATOR's game hence no one can give you short term targets.. Hope you understand the logic now.
545.4. Imhilli| Link| Bookmark|
January 26, 2023 4:29:57 PM
IPO Guru (1200+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
544.2. GuruMahadev| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 5:18:21 PM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
Tomorrow planning to add one unit.
544.3. GuruMahadev| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 5:26:16 PM
Top Contributor (200+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
Rocket 🚀🚀🚀🚀🚀
544.4. arvindarvind| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 5:31:28 PM
Top Contributor (900+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Date is 23 Why share not reacted on 24th? Even reaction was wrong side and closed in LC. As i see lot of retailer are present in Chaman so unlit unless they not exit lot of pressure will be here.
@ A Prem. Yes, i am holding. you have bought it at the right time/right price, 1) it is not expected to go below your buying level. 2) As per the Yesterday News, it is expected a UC today. 3) Today is 8th trading session, on 11th trading day, circuit limit revise, whenever it happens, there will be rise in buying volume even in bad stocks too, it is even good stock.
544.15. arvindarvind| Link| Bookmark|
January 25, 2023 7:10:12 PM
Top Contributor (900+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Since they have find environment clearance it will take 1 to 2 year from now to complete the project. Price movement to upward direction will be started any time soon. And when it will start it will not stop move to 4 to 5 times. It is my guess based on this project.
What is wrong with this share? Instead of going up, it has started going down. I think in SME IPOs, same people keep on buying and to apply in the new IPOs just to take the IPO listing benefits, those same people have to sell the existing shares too. Now, I am trapped here in this share and unable to find the reason of this share going down. What will happen to Hem securities if it goes below even their buying price? SSingh, Noorul, Ravichandran, Lokes-Any views about the future of Chaman metallics?
542.1. Trueinfo| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 8:57:41 AM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
@ Ajay Khosla, brother your post doesn't appear logical. The share is still trading with more than 50% gain from the issue price with ample exit opportunities.So, how are you feeling trapped? . If you have bought in preopen or after listing, then that's the gamble, you have taken. I don't think, you can blame 'Hem' for that. Also, you really can't blame people for profit booking or loss containment. It's all individual choice, sir.
Thanks for the reply. I am not blaming Hem here. You are right about my trapping guess too. Instead of having good business and bright future, this share is going down unexpectedly, so, I wanted to have the views of people here especially people like you and other seniors about the future of this company because
542.3. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 9:58:15 AM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
Still selling pressure is there but I don't expect it to go much lower as it will negatively affect the sentiment for upcoming IPO from Hem - Earthsthal. It is better than many other smes as it is providing an easy opportunity to exit as well as enter the stock.
542.4. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 10:14:04 AM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Ajay Bhai, People need to money to apply to other IPOs hence selling is there. ‘SMEs me paisa medium term me hee banta hai’ Please note my words and check the performance of previously listed companies. Please don’t expect daily UC or LC… SME ki apni chal hai.. Jo aapko tracking se samjh aayegi. So, don’t panic. Relax!! 😊
Thanks for the answers SSingh and trueinfo. What do you both think about its future predictions? I have observed that most of the SME IPOs prove beneficial to those who get the IPOs at the initial issue price and the guys who buy the shares on the 1st day or afterwards loose money in majority of the cases. Also, in SME segment, generally what the people or experts say don't happen and its always the opposite of what they suggest after the listing day.
542.6. SSingh| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 12:34:05 PM
IPO Guru (1400+ Posts, 800+ Likes)
Only HEM and Operators have idea about future. :)
542.7. Imhilli| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 1:06:59 PM
IPO Guru (1200+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
There is neither UC nor LC for last 2 days and good volumes of shares changing hands which is good sign. Hopefully it is consolidating here before taking a upward move.
Company has posted Profit of 7 cr for half year FY 23. Thus if we assume annualize profit of Rs 14 cr and PE of 14 ( Based on peers like Lloyds Metal , SAL steel , Jindal Steel) , Market cap should be around 196 cr. Current o/s shares is 2.41 cr. so price per share should be approx 81 Rs.
Look at valuation , daily changes in price does not matter. (Note : valuation might change if there is change in profit figure, for eg if annualize profit is 10 cr than market cap will be around 140 cr , price per share will be 57.8 Rs)
Wait for the results to decide whether to hold this stock or not.
542.9. Trueinfo| Link| Bookmark|
January 24, 2023 2:02:13 PM
IPO Guru (1800+ Posts, 1700+ Likes)
All depends upon your holding capacity and risk appetite. Company no doubt is good, but price play is difficult to predict. Agree with your observations in latter post regarding behavior of SME IPOs broadly, but surprises always remain in store. My view has been always that 'avoid herd mentality'. It can kill any good share and prop up bad one. Remember how TCS buyback offer was killed due to same as Anil Singhvi announced on ZEE business about sureshot profitability and it resulted in loss to everyone. So take your decision seeing the trend so far. You may read between the lines to get the point home.
Thanks Trueinfo, SSingh, Shalin, IPO Share, Imhilli, Manan and healthslayer for your answers. trueinfo-I was also wondering that how can it happen that everybody here was so hopefull after the UC of 58.20 that this will share will only go up and break all the records. I too got swayed by the comments here and bought 2 lots without even thinking that the operators nowadays are so smart they will always outplay not only your move but also the LM's move and this is the best example to learn. Anyways, things like these happen and we all learn from our mistakes. Ravichandran ji bought some shares in pre open too. Sir-What do you think about its future course?
@Ajay Khosla, I have added 3 more lots today. The company has great future, which was confirmed by their exchange filing after market hours, yesterday. This should turn around today. I would suggest to hold for 12 months and beyond, this could be a multi bagger once expansion is materialized.
Disclosure: I having huge exposure in Chaman, my opinion could be biased unintentionally.
Thank you Ravi ji for your answer. I too made up my mind 2 days ago that I will hold this share at least for 4-6 months. Also, Although the news above is very positive but seeing the volume in buying and selling orders till this time, it doesn't seem that it will hit the UC today but I hope that it starts happening soon.
It seems everybody's guess about this share went wrong at least for short term. Same thing happened with Kotyark industries. Even after back to back fantastic news like plant extension for glycerin production, amalgamation of Yamuna bio energy etc., the buyers didn't find any interest in that company and its been 3-4 months, the share price is dwindling between the range of 370 to 430. Lets see how Chaman behaves in the long run and I hope that our hard earned money don't get wasted.
542.14. Manan Surana| Link| Bookmark|
January 25, 2023 12:26:24 PM
Top Contributor (800+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
@ajay , kotyrak industries was also listed as a SME share , on the price of 51 rs. , it gave multibagger returns within 8 months , and rn it is up 750 percent from it's listing price , it will complete it's 2 years in market in November 2023
Hello Manan The central theme of my message was to make comparison between 2 same situations. Just like in kotyark, good news of amalgamation as well as expansion of production facility was not able to get the price to a higher level, in the same way, it may or may not be possible that in Chaman, a good news of new plant will get the company to hit UCs immediately. The news can or cannot make an impact at least for short term. In long term, it should definitely make an impact. I am just an year old in SME segment but I think this logic applies to SME as well as in main segment but it is more applicable to SME segment because the operators can play their game easily here due to lesser money involved for short term. I may be wrong altogether in my analysis and please ignore my message if you don't like it. I am learning by reading the views of the seniors here and I am very thankful to them for answering the queries of newbies like me.
Was expecting two UCs after listing and then four LCs, then current price would have some where around 62-67 but isne listing pe hi char LC laga diye :)