When retailers offloaded completely, This can move up sharply. This is Operators game to snach shares from retailers. Retailers need money in short term, So they are selling.
1140.5. Have Faith 🙏| Link| Bookmark|
September 29, 2021 8:22:02 PM
Top Contributor (500+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
Anirudh majority of retailers are out ... everytime it is not operator ....if don''t have anything to say just say waiting for retailers to get out and operators are there
@Have Faith, Did you have shares ? If yes, then how retailers are out. Don''t have patience of holding 1 month then why you invest. Put amount in FD and enjoy fixed interest without risk. See on money control forum are retailers actually out or not, they are crying.
1140.7. Have Faith 🙏| Link| Bookmark|
September 29, 2021 9:19:39 PM
Top Contributor (500+ Posts, 100+ Likes)
Retailers out doesn''t mean 100 percent retailers will be out it is impossible use some common sense 35 percent was retail quota and still 5 percent are their and u will say retailers are not out operators are there ...and don''t make any judgement on basis of money control forum
1138.1. NeoLongus| Link| Bookmark|
September 24, 2021 11:44:18 AM
IPO Mentor (800+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
@Have Faith - This car clearly has a slow puncture. I''m holding about 150 shares (acquired in the IPO) and I''m still holding strong and my reasons are as follows:
> All its peers, Cars24, Droom, Spinny have raised large sums from global investors at very rich valuations - info available on Google > Similar car resale platforms in other emerging countries continue to attract crazy amount of capital - info available on Google > The Company is a rare example of an Internet era company with profitability and strong +ve cash flows and hence is priced dearly, as the MARKET is telling us > Unlike Zomato / Swiggy, (which are unique and won''t have very many lookalikes soon), eventually there will be multiple companies of its type listed in the local market and this is a negative for this Company and space > I''m of the view that if they can deliver growth and show traction, their profitability will improve exponentially and the market will reward them for it > @ about 75x FY21 P/E, its well below the 100x P/E which seems to be the benchmark for Internet era companies. However, the key factor here remains growth because that has been flattish for the Company in the last 3 reported fiscals > The 15%+ loss that I''m sitting on is painful but I don''t see too many fundamental investment opportunities in the market at the current level for me to book a loss here and move my investment and hence since this remains a fundamental play for me so I''m holding tight for now. If I don''t see the Company reporting growth in the next few quarters, I''ll have strong reasons to book losses and alight this car
NITEENIPO - Principally, I''m against the concept of averaging because its like throwing good money after bad and being stubborn about our thought process even though the market is telling us otherwise. Unless, there is a deep market correction which allows us to buy certain securities at great pricing, I never average. But this is just me and we all have different philosophies. For CarTrade, I''m not sure how much averaging will help coz its continuously slipping on low volumes and needs some fundamental or technical triggers.
I''ve shared my perspective on Ami & Devyani earlier and you can check them out on the page with all my posts. At current prices, I feel, its better to exit them both completely.
Hi NeoLongus - I see your thoughts on Car Trade; I do see the delivery volumns are so high like >50% every day; Felt like someone is accumulating nicely even though its making lows every other day. I am also positive on the business that they do, I feel like its less asset burden company and as long as they show some positivity in growth that should fuel the share price in coming quarters; especially looking for Q2 numbers and decide.
Chip shortage causes demand spillover in used car market https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/industry/auto/cars-uvs/chip-shortage-causes-demand-spillover-in-used-car-market/articleshow/86161037.cms
1134. NeoLongus| Link| Bookmark|
August 30, 2021 11:28:43 AM
IPO Mentor (800+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
This one''s sulking even on a day like today! Really disappointed with the listing enthusiasm shown by this one!
Spinny, Cars24 etc all will become publicly listed in the next few years...will become a game of execution and operational excellence as the space and market opportunity is huge and one of these 3 or someone will dominate. I''ve already absorbed the listing day loss and holding steady for now. Keep minting!
Car is going down the Hill guys hold on tight... its just a roller coaster ride... uphill will come soon those who were waiting for a decent listing gain are putting pressure. Just give it a couple of weeks it should be in the 1800 range.
It takes 1-2 months for an IPO stock to generate interest again in the minds of investors. Hold, cartrade, aptus, chemplast, krsnaa, devyani, exxaro, nuvoco.. these are good stocks... within a year some of them might get double. And even if you get atleast 7% after a year, it''s still a win win in terms of returns. If you can hold it then you should. I have all of these in my portfolio with averaged out prices.
Got alloted in CarT and aptus (2/2). Didnot get Chemplast, did not apply Nuvoco. 1/2 in Devyani not any lot in any other previous 3 IPO (Exarro/ Windlas/ Krsnaa, 0/2). Sold Devyani partially in friends account, took my money. Gifted rest of shares. Sold Aptus both lots at no loss. Sold CarT both lot at loss (Adjusted loss with gain made earlier this year). If anyone can remain invested CarT and Aptus, may perform in long term. In short term, there is no visible upside. Market moves on others sentiments and I may be wrong in my trade but took these decisions after factoring every thing at that time.
HNI ka khud ka paisa to laga nahi hota retailer ki tarah. Market se paisa utha ke kharid to lete hai share. Uske baad HNI cost na nikle to bech bech ke selling pressure banate hai. Uske baad retailer bhi panic selling karne lagta hai.
I feel no point in accumulating this stock which is down almost 10% post listing. Make it reach at least listing price, anyone can enter there and hope for a quick 10-15%. I personally exited at 1515
I believe now the time has come when the market distinguishes between men and boys. So buy good stocks with strong fundamentals basically a value stock. By the way, I ain''t going to buy this stock. As "If we attribute super earnings of FY21 on its equity, then the asking price is at a P/E of around 73.38 and if we exclude accounting adjustments for deferred tax and attribute it on equity, then the asking price is at a P/E of around 199.26. Thus the issue is priced exorbitantly. (at the upper price bands)".