66. Rafiq| Link| Bookmark|
February 15, 2023 12:41:39 PM
Top Contributor (400+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
There are many negative points to skip this IPO. 1)Low Subscription at last day - around 3 Times over all 2)NSE platform not a single lot applied by MF/FII or Domestic institution 3)23% of IPO fund used for IPO management 4)Not a Manufacturer but trader/Wholesaler 5)Only for couple of day this stock GMP in positive else in negative 6)IPO share price costly
Although I am comfortable with the financials of the company and the team managing IPO. However I am personally skiiping it as the money flow in grey market is not that encouraging. I peronally dont like to risk my capital only on the basis of financials. There has to be some institutional support in grey market.
58. Romy HNI| Link| Bookmark|
February 15, 2023 9:51:35 AM
IPO Mentor (500+ Posts, 400+ Likes)
I have gone through various messages shared by fellow members.....have also seen the financials......
I have asked my frd who is active in IPO market and he said, its a gud thing that company has transparently shown actual expenses in prospectus rather to hide anything and issue expenses always be as per agreement between parties and all agreement submitted to all authorities and there is no crime or non legal things in this scenario. We should take this positive that company believe in proper corporate governance. Plz think in different manner also. thnxs
Tell me one Thing Being 'BANIYA' from Rajasthan (Baniyas are world Famous as Business tycoon)
He must have Fought for True Expenses If he had tried must have Visited Other LM and Might have taken opinion from Other LM in the market
If he is true Entrepreneur He must have Chosen best possible rates which are 5-10 % prevailing in market.
Imagine If u want to make Big 'DHANDHA' Just as Diru Bhai or Damani They Fight for 1 paisa.
Think Agarwal Promoter taken loan @13% of bargain with Banks could have got @8-10% prevailing rates in Market So the Additional 3% saved will be Increased profit for shareholders
As a shareholder u always want Minimum cost n maximum profit
Those Retail investors applying 120000 suppose , only 91200 going into Company progress.
Smartly U will get Return on 91200 Rs only. As balance has Gone into pockets of LM.
100% agree with ur point arjun bhai, but u r very much active in sme ipo and u must know that in most of the IPO, major portion of ipo proceeds go to operator or LM via different modes and instead of knowing this everyone apply. Ateast agarwal shown properly in document , so its gud that investor se koi chori chupa kaam nhi kr rhe.
57.4. arvindarvind| Link| Bookmark|
February 14, 2023 7:03:50 PM
Top Contributor (900+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Arjun sir Your opinion matter a lot to us. Please tell us apply or not
@Arjun Rajkot Company is going to get more than 7 crs as premium. Even after making issue expenses of 24% of issue size, the promoters are not going to loose even a single rupee. Is there any rule for issue expenses and violated by the Company? Why SEBI may ask the company for these expenses, unless there is any rule ? Even after listing, the company promoters may gain more. If not satisfied, I think one should not apply and if applied and got allotment, which is not so easy to get, book profit/loss on listing. Why to apply in each and every SME? Is there any rule for investors by SEBI to apply in all issues. Leave it and have a nice sleep. SLEEP AND LET OTHERS SLEEP.
56. snipperRaj| Link| Bookmark|
February 14, 2023 10:39:14 PM
Top Contributor (300+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
Glass business is promising, scalable. Company promoters are quite experienced in this field, company having good revenue, and good profit margins. Applying with decent force.
Many here are my family members and Respect my comments.
I request to take Ur own call. Do not blindly apply or avoid on my Call.
Request to take Ur own opinion
As far as Company Agarwal is Compared, I am Not Applying Only for two Reasons 1. Trading Business is not Good for Long term. 2. Some Red flags just as High Issue Expenses Debt etc makes an avoid.
Request memebers to take Ur own Decision wisely and Please don't follow me.
Listing May happen anywhere But I am Happy avoiding this Let it list anywhere I invest in Good business Not in Speculative Stock operator driven
Final verdict:
Not applying due to aforesaid reasonS. Let operator take this anywhere Members take Ur Decision and Accordingly ur Risk Appetite U may apply or avoid. Only food thing SMC market Maker But Last Few issue like Uma Pritika as standing around its Price.
Again Take Ur Call! I am applying 1. Robu.in 2. Seal Matic
Arjun sir, I am following you since last one year, sir in past your suggestion helped me lot in sme ipo, please continue your suggestion avoiding nonsense comments of some persons , your reviews helps me alot
Suppose You have earn or Your money is Saved in bad issue.
I never asked for profit nor have given in case of loss.
So Take Your own Decision as it's Your money. I shall not be responsible
Thanks
54.3. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
February 14, 2023 10:15:20 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
@Arjun Rajkot Thanks for your guidance please. I request you to continue with your unbiased opinion. Your good work helps forum members to take informed decision. Of course ultimate decision is of individual only but one needs proper information to reach a decision and this is where you are of immense help.
54.4. SONMAYA| Link| Bookmark|
February 15, 2023 8:31:26 AM
IPO Guru (1300+ Posts, 500+ Likes)
Very well said...Btw there r many option available to invest.why to stuck to this one forget this IPO and let's move on with other option..in the End SUNO SABKI KARO APNE MANKI.
Response only.. of 22 cr... Just 2.5 such low subscribe is tension and gp 0 thinks of avoiding...
Baat dam ki boli Arjun bhai..me janta hu Naruto dollec me bachaya tha ham sab ko... Apko salam hai Arjun sir ji
Aap comments karta rahiyea...
Sentimental fayada leve che Gp low che Susbc low che IPO jaipur se che Dam nayi che....
Promoter ne pachi...bada Kam nave che trading che
52. ipo share| Link| Bookmark|
February 14, 2023 7:24:07 PM
IPO Guru (1500+ Posts, 700+ Likes)
There is huge difference of opinion amongst members with regard to this sme. More importantly, serious questions/issues have been raised here with regard to fundamentals and work culture of the company. I have been reading comments of @Arjun Rajkot for so long and have been benefited a lot in past from his expertise. I take his comments quite seriously. The question is why would he discourage us and what benefit he will get by posting against any company. I don't find reasons to take risk here unless Gurus recommend. @Noorul, MRavi, lokes - Dear guides please share your strategy here. Thanks 🙏
52.1. arvindarvind| Link| Bookmark|
February 14, 2023 7:31:19 PM
Top Contributor (900+ Posts, 200+ Likes)
@ArjunRajkot had you gone through RHP of Pritika ? it gave good returns. In that IPO also Issue related expenses were 1.85crore (19.64%) of the total issue of 9.41crore. Source: Page 62 in Pritika RHP You are senior member, can you please explain why you didn't raise questions in Pritika where also 19.64% of the issue size were used as issue expenses and same LM -GYR Capital and Market Maker SMC Global ?
EKI energy mai auditor ne books mai profit and revenue ko lekar saval uthaye hai.. serious concern.. Stock lower circuit since last 2 days.kya bolna hai expert ka..kya krna chahiye
Baap re baap..more than 100 msg here for this ipo..lagta hai sab expert ne theka le liya, investors ko aware krne ka, Aisa lagta hai sab experts ne Aaj Tak sab shares mai profit hi kamaya hai, loss to hua hi nhi..itne knowledgeable log hai..