MOIL Limited IPO Message Board (Page 5)

ANSWER TO SMART INVESTOR .... (KAB SE PUCH RAHA THA... BAHUT JAROORI HAI..)

1 question. What do you know about this company and this sector?

ma ne apko yahi question 2-3 time puchha per kabhi answ. de nahi sake.

ANSWER: I DONT KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THIS COMPANY NOR DO I KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THIS SECTOR. SMART INVESTORS LIKE U HAVE ALREADY DONE A LOT OF RESEARCH & ANALYSIS AND ALMOST EVERY CHANGU, MANGU AND CHHANGU IN INDIA KNOW THAT THIS IS A DEBT FREE COMPANY, GOOD EPS, PE, BOOK VALUE, FUN- DA - MENTALS ETC....

I ALSO READ THE RESEARCH REPORTS OF ALL THE BROKERAGE HOUSES IN INDIA...

BUT EVEN KNOWING ALL THESE ABOVE FACTS, I ADVISED TO KOOOT THIS STOCK .....

BUT U WILL NOT UNDERSTAND THIS... U JUST GO AND BUY MORE MOIL.. KEEP RESEARCHING THIS COMPANY... KEEP WATCHING EPS, BOOK VALUE... P/E... A

YEH SHARE MARKET HAI.... BACCHON KE KHELANE KI CHHEZZE NAHIN HAI.... GALAT DECISION HO JAAYE TO THUKKAAII (LONG TERM) HO JAATI HAI.... GALAT DECISION KO IMMEDIATELY STOP KAR LENA CHAHIYE... OTHERWISE LONG TERM HO JAATA HAI....

DEAR SMART INV.

THIS IS NOT LISTED IN F&O...ELSE I WOULD HV KOOOTED THIS.

Dear M Gupta @2222.

Ap Future SELL kyu nahi karate agar iteana confident hai to ?

1 question. What do you know about this company and this sector?

ma ne apko yahi question 2-3 time puchha per kabhi answ. de nahi sake.

Hi Santosh. @2233

Jai ho Santosh Baba ki. Jo bhavishya vani karate hai.
Itana Confident ha to Future SELL karo Bahot kamavo ge.

1 more question. Do you have any study or just throwing something ?

moil....buy between 350-375 within 7 days

Operaters nay NHPC,SJVNL, MOIL ko aisay thoka ki yah PSU Mama ban gai, issay 1 baat sabit hui ki operater kay samnay govt. Usi tarah hi jaisay tophan kay agay tinka.

Hi Shreedhar, I am having 50 shares of MOIL at Rs. 480/-. Could you please advise, should I hold or should I book the loss. Is there any scope to come up this stock. Thanks in advance.

2190. devulapalliC

Our dog predicted 25% - 30% fall in index in 2011.

I had given food in two pockets. It chose the pocket that said a fall in 2011!

MOIL LONG TERM TARGET BELOW 375....

GOVT. IS NOT A FOOL THAT IT GAVE ITS SHARE AT 375 CHEAP TO U...

MOIL KA LONG TERM HO RAHA HAI...

DEAR ALL, SELL ALL UR MOIL IMMEDIATELY OTHERWISE "ISAKA LONG TERM HO JAAYEGA"...

LONG TERM MEANS - 4-5 YEARS

I have applied 85 shares but not alloted any sharesand not get refund till date.

I have neuther recieved refind for MOIL nor for SCIL.
Though i opted for ECS mode & for last all IPOs i recieved un due time but this time i have not recieved for both...3 lacs fans gaya..poor service by karvy

Mr DevenMehta,

Generally do you receive the refund by ECS or Cheque ??? If it is cheque you will receive by today or tomorrow. ECS funds already credited by 13th December 2010

Hi Friends.. I had applied with 2 lac application and the funds debited from my account on 6th December. But Unfortunately I have not received any allotment and the height is that I have also NOT RECEIVED the Refund ... Can I request you friends to share your views on what should I do now? Is there anyone else with same problem?

2221. snehal Coal india and MOIL ... I would prefer Coal india at the price 200~240 not above that. If MOIL then 350~400 is the entry price.

Those who are holding MOIL are advised to book their loss/profit immediately because retail public is long in this counter heavily....

unlike COAL where most of the retailers had already sold in grey and rest of the retailers sold immediately on listing...

so COAL may(or may not.. depending upon market ) rise further in long term but MOIL will certainly loot and kooOt retailers like SJVNL did..

SJVNL gave 5% discount listed at reasonable premium giving appoc Rs. 2000 return per one lac but public did not sell... they hold it for long term and got koOoted and looted....

now similar story is happening here as well... Public did not sell a single share on listing... infact some overconfident investors bought on listing and got looted and koOoted.....

now all are repenting their decision and justifying that this is a long term share... but i tell u guys... this share will be further koOoted and those who are long will be further looted... like SJVNL...

baad main "na nigalate banega an ugalate banega"....

so sell MOIL immediately..... to save your hard earned money.....

Disclaimer: I dont have any Long/ Short position nor i intend to plus this share after some fall... infact I want to short this share but because this is not an FNO stock I cant do this... u can check my messages , i did short sell on listing day and I advised the same on this Board on real time basis.... when the scrip was 535 then also I suggested to short for an immediate target of 499 then i again gave a call to short with next target of 450 which it could not go on listing day...

but after a few stablised sessions this share will be koOoted to 400 levels where I will again ask those "FUN - DA - MENTAL" buyers to come and buy and get kooOted to save others...

"YEH PUBLIC HAI YEH KUCH NAHI JAANTI HAI...
TEH KOOOT JAATI HAI ... YEH LOOT JAATI HAI...
KITNA BHI SAMJHAO PAR NAHI MANTI HAI....

YEH PUBLIC HAI....."

any one say me which one is the good stock among the coal india and MOIL ? please

@ 2219. Dear Subramanian Nagarajan

Most of the HNI's apply for more then 20 Lacs which you may see in the basis of allotment.

You may see that in the 544 Shares catagory there were 122 applications which i guess was a mistake by those people who considered the price after discount of 5%.

After that you can see that the retail catagory got 2 applications for 1190 Shares, 2 applications for 2125 Shares, 5 applications for 2533 Shares & 25 applications for 5321 Shares.

Hence i feel that my calculation is right.


In the scenario where 1 Lac was the limit for Retail :

Why would people apply for 2 Lacs in HNI catagory when they are sure they would get more allotment by applying for 1 Lac in Retail catagory. You may see the record of past issues if you wish to.

Hence I feel my calculation is right

@ 2218. Dear PRS,

Mr. K.V. Subba Rao is almost right. 99% of the HNIs will not apply in the 1 lakh limit. They will try only in their quota.

Some retailers might have applied from 1 lakh to 2 lakhs. But even now most of them are applying with maximum of 1 lakh amout.

@ 2217. K V Subba Rao

Sir I think that all those who have applied for shares between 272 & 527 would have definitely applied for 255 shares if the limit was 1 Lac. Hence the issue would have been oversubscribed by 21.88 times.